Shaping places through strategic commissioning
Author: Dr Laura White, Localis & Essex CC - Sep 28, 2011
Localis has launched a major report, with cross party support (see quotes below), at the Labour party conference in Liverpool, describing how councils can deliver better public services by shifting towards a more ‘strategic commissioning’ approach.
‘Commission Impossible? Shaping places through strategic commissioning’ - produced in partnership with Essex County Council and Mears – draws upon the findings of a recent survey of over 100 council leaders and chief executives carried out by Localis showing that 4 in 5 councils across England are considering taking a greater strategic commissioning role in the delivery of local public services in the near future.
Traditionally councils have provided many of their services themselves, and although in recent years there has been a gradual move towards commissioning services from other organisations, recent government figures show that total non-external local government expenditure is approximately £65bn .
But with rising demands on council services and increased pressure on budgets following cuts to central government grant, the trend towards new providers looks set to accelerate significantly – for every council that believes more services will be delivered in-house in the near future, there are 16 more that anticipate less in-house delivery, instead predicting a shift in provision to voluntary organisations (82%), public sector shared initiatives (81%), SMEs (75%) and large companies (68%).
‘Commission Impossible’ argues that local authorities have a once in a generation opportunity to dramatically improve local services by shifting to a strategic commissioning approach. The report also outlines the importance of being ‘provider-neutral’, focusing on the needs of local residents over and above political ideology.
A strategic commissioning approach offers substantial benefits for both councils and local residents. These include, as the report outlines, delivering services in more efficient ways, ensuring the provision of services which deliver the most important outcomes for residents, stimulating local enterprise by creating new markets (and new jobs) in the provision of local services, and an increased emphasis on the scrutiny of services.
The report offers a series of recommendations for central and local government, including:
• Focus on outcomes not processes – Central Government should promote national availability of data to compare provider performance to enable commissioners to make informed decisions. Councils should also be open-minded about who provides the services.
• Support a thriving market for all sectors – Central Government should support councils to open up services to all organisations including small and voluntary organisations, by evidencing social return on investment and reducing procurement barriers.
• Redefine risk – Councils should redefine risk to ensure that money is spent on services which deliver the long term benefits.
• Create smarter, more flexible contracts – Councils should ‘value test’ and re-negotiate their contracts more extensively.
The report has received broad support from all three main political parties, as well as councils and the private and voluntary sectors:
Rt. Hon. Hazel Blears MP (who contributed the foreword to the publication, and spoke at the report launch) said:
“By commissioning more effectively and collectively not only will councils benefit from greater efficiencies that will allow savings to be made in a difficult financial climate, but working with local people and giving them greater involvement and responsibility over the way that their money is being spent will bring together service providers and service users in partnership to drive continual improvement. The report’s conclusions are relevant for central government and councils of all political persuasions, and will undoubtedly become increasingly pertinent in the years ahead.”
Rt. Hon. Oliver Letwin MP, Minister for Policy said:
“Strategic commissioning is important for opening up public services and providing choice to service users. As the Government seeks to encourage choice, accountability, and fairness in public services, it is an important time to consider the role of local government in helping to achieve these aims. This report provides a useful analysis of strategic commissioning, and offers practical lessons for how councils can improve the lives of local residents.”
Lord Shipley, former Liberal Democrat Leader of Newcastle City Council said:
“For me, strategic commissioning is about building social capital and empowering people from all walks of life to take more responsibility for what happens in their neighbourhoods and communities. Neighbourhood councils, cooperative trading companies, mutuals and social enterprises will all prove key components of successful strategic commissioning. This report makes a vital contribution to enabling strategic commissioning to be a success.”
Sir Merrick Cockell, Local Government Association Chairman said:
“With a Government committed to decentralising power to local government and beyond, we have a once in a generation opportunity to drastically change local services for the better. As this excellent report makes clear, taking a more strategic commissioning approach can help us deliver more efficient services, better outcomes for residents as well as to support local enterprise. It offers food for thought for councils across the country, and I urge council leaders from all parties to consider its recommendations.”
Cllr Peter Martin, Leader of Essex County Council said:
‘This study of how we can commission more strategically is especially timely as councils balance tight budgets with the key agendas of decentralisation, choice and diversity. The report addresses the challenge of putting into practice the fundamentals we already know – it shows that it’s vitally important that we are really listening to what our communities need, and keeping an open mind as to how we meet that need, in order to provide the best services and the best value for money’
Sir Stephen Bubb, Chief Executive of the Association of Chief Executives of Voluntary Organisations (ACEVO) said:
“As local councils increasingly take on the role of strategic service commissioners, it is vital that they are equipped to encourage the development of diverse local markets, supporting a range of providers including those from the voluntary and community sector. Localis has produced an important and timely report which takes a fresh and constructive approach to issues around local commissioning.”
Alex Thomson, Chief Executive of Localis, said:
“Local government faces a major challenge in delivering quality services in a time of austerity. Quite rightly, many councils are thinking creatively about how they can achieve this, and adopting a strategic commissioning approach is the best way to help councils deliver better services for less money.”
Alan Long, Executive Director of Mears, said:
“Commissioning has a vital role to play in improving the quality of life for groups and individuals which is why we welcomed the opportunity to support Localis and Essex County Council in delivering this valuable report.”
Alex Thomson speaking on BBC Radio Stoke
Further devolution deals fail to materialise
by Dan Peters, The MJ
Alex Thomson in the top 100 most influential in local government
by Rachel Dalton, LGC
Public Land, Public Good
Posted in Reform and Personalisation of Public Services
Building the Future: Accelerating Housing Delivery in the South East
Posted in Planning, Housing and Growth
To bid or not to bid: calculating the costs of competitive funding processes
Posted in Democracy and Devolution
Meeting the challenge in Barnet
Posted in Reform and Personalisation of Public Services
- "Localis is fast gaining a reputation for pre-empting the localist agenda, producing thought provoking research and practical policy ideas"Anthony Seldon, author and political commentator
- "Localis’ commitment to decentralisation crosses party boundaries, and their research illuminates policy problems with new practical thinking"Prof George Jones, LSE
- "Localis offers a great blend of a passion for innovation, grounded practical ideas and unswerving belief in the possibilities of local governance"Derek Myers, Chief Executive, Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea